Lack of consistency and monitoring will nullify B-BBEE

| 0 Comments
KeithLevenstein.jpgThe newly gazetted Revised Codes of Good Practice need consistency more than anything else, says Keith Levenstein, CEO of B-BBEE advisory company EconoBEE.

Of concern is that there are differing interpretations of the codes, and how to earn points, says Levenstein. In some cases the codes are slightly unclear, but in others they are clear - but the agency or approved auditor simply chooses, via a procedural policy, to follow a different interpretation.
 

The status quo is that verification and resultant BEE certificates are inconsistent. Not by a fraction of a point, but by as much as 20 or more points.

“Shopping around for a verification agency is a current reality,” says Levenstein. While inconsistency still exists, we will still see companies change agencies to earn more points.

If agencies can issue such diverse scores, the whole purpose of verification is defeated, and since BEE certificates need to be verified, the whole B-BBEE concept will be destroyed, he says.

What has lead to differing interpretations?

When the Codes were first published in 2007, the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) stated that verification was encouraged, but not mandatory and the concept of self-rating became popular.

“Initially, we were in favour of self-rating or unregulated assessment because it encouraged businesses to become compliant and embrace the initial stages of transformation,” says Levenstein.

However, it transpired that many businesses simply inflated their scorecards to meet a level of their choosing.

Therefore, a standard was required to ensure that a company was rated according to standard methods, procedures, interpretations and calculations. The South African National Accreditation System (SANAS) was appointed to accredit agencies and the DTI published the "Verification Manual" - a guideline of procedures for verification.

In 2010 it became mandatory to use a SANAS-accredited agency to produce a valid certificate. Subsequently IRBA has been appointed as a second regulator to approve auditors to perform B-BBEE verification.

However, each agency: SANAS, the Association of BEE Verification Agencies (ABVA - an organisation representing the interests of verification agencies), the DTI and BEE consultants, each have their own differing interpretations, says Levenstein.

“If agencies can legitimately issue such diverse scores the whole purpose of verification is defeated, and since BEE certificates need to be verified, the whole B-BBEE concept will be destroyed.”

The relevant parties (the BEE Council, DTI Minister, BEE Unit of the DTI, SANAS and IRBA) must get involved by issuing guidelines, interpretations and practice notes, implores Levenstein.

It has been suggested that a BEE Ombudsman be appointed to decide on interpretations or alternatively obtain an interpretation from the BEE Council or a court of law to ensure consistency. The DTI included the concept of a BEE Commissioner in their proposed Bill. However it has not yet been enacted.

Contact Keith Levenstein on (011) 483-1190.

Leave a comment


SmartProcurement Newsletter
X

Please enter your details below to receive the SmartProcurement Newsletter for FREE on a regular basis.

As part of the SmartProcurement Newsletter you will be receiving World Class Procurement News, Tools, Tips, Tactics, Procurement Training updates, Upcoming Events, and the latest Procurement Career Openings.

* Email Address:
* Title:
* First Name:
* Surname:
* Company:
  Position:
* Country:
* Public / Private:

 

Career opportunites

Purchasing and Supply Manager

  • <500 000 >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Supply Chain
Purchasing and Supply ManagerThe CSIR has a vacancy ...More

Senior Manager Public Sector

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Projects / Category Management
 Senior Manager Public SectorTotal Cost to Company: R1.1mil ...More

Senior Manager: Mining

  • >500 000 Gauteng Industrial Engineer Permanent Projects / Category Management
Senior Manager: MiningTotal Cost to Company: R900k – ...More

SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGER

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Supply Chain
SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGER(Total Cost to Company R750k – ...More

Master Data Management Advisor

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Projects / Category Management
 MASTER DATA MANAGEMENT ADVISOR(Total Cost to Company R750k ...More

PRO - Performance Reporting

  • >500 000 Permanent Procurement Consultant Procurement Management Projects / Category Management
PRO - Performance ReportingTotal Cost to Company: R800k ...More

PRO - Risk & Governance

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Projects / Category Management
PRO - Risk & GovernanceTotal Cost to Company: ...More

Supply Chain Site Manager

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Supply Chain
Supply Chain Site ManagerTotal Cost to Company R1mil ...More

Chief Financial Officer

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Officer / Specialist
Chief Financial OfficerTotal Cost to Company R1.5mil – ...More

Process Engineer- WMS

  • <500 000 >500 000 Industrial Engineer Permanent Projects / Category Management Western Cape
Process Engineer- WMS(Total Cost to Company R350K – ...More

Forecast Analyst

  • <500 000 Analyst Permanent Procurement Management Western Cape
Forecast Analyst(Total Cost to Company R350K – R500K) Location: ...More

Group Category Manager: Indirects

  • >500 000 Permanent Procurement Management Projects / Category Management Western Cape
Group Category Manager: Indirects(Total Cost to Company R700K ...More

Group Category Specialist: Chemical

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Officer / Specialist Strategic Sourcing
Group Category Specialist: Chemical(Total Cost to Company R700K ...More

Sourcing Specialist - 3rd party

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Officer / Specialist Strategic Sourcing
Sourcing Specialist - 3rd partyTotal Cost to Company ...More

Global Procurement Lead (Processing)

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Supply Chain
 Global Procurement Lead (Processing)Location: JohannesburgTotal Cost to Company ...More

Global Supplier Performance Manager

  • >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Supply Chain
Global Supplier Performance Manager Location: Johannesburg  Cost to ...More

Group Customer Service Lead

  • <500 000 >500 000 Analyst Gauteng Permanent Procurement Officer / Specialist
Group Customer Service Lead  Location: Johannesburg As the ...More

Business Intelligence Manager

  • <500 000 >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management Supplier / Business Development
Business Intelligence Manager Location: JohannesburgLead the development, implementation, optimization ...More

Group Procurement Manager

  • <500 000 >500 000 Gauteng Permanent Procurement Management
Group Procurement Manager Location: Johannesburg  A Global Organization ...More

Commodity Manager Packaging

  • >500 000 Commodities Gauteng Permanent Projects / Category Management
Commodity Manager Packaging  Location: Johannesburg Salary: R850k– R1.1mil ...More